“In friendship both fairness and caring are valuable. Although friendship does not usually center on formulating rules and applying them to cases, it typically does involve, as Marilyn Friedman has pointed out, a division of responsibilities in a more or less extensive mutual support system. A good friendship is fair about such divisions. Such fairness may even be a requirement of caring. Fairness in friendship also requires responsiveness to personal deserts or worthiness. If anything, to be a good friend one needs a better sense of fairness than to be a good citizen or soldier, an idea that makes good sense of Aristotle’s report that people say that “when [we] are friends [we] have no need of justice, while when [we] are just [we] need friendship as well, and the truest form of justice is thought to be a friendly quality.’ If “justice” here is meant to suggest enforcement, the idea seems sound. Responsiveness where enforcement is not forthcoming is a greater test of one’s fairness than where there is possible recourse to sanctions. If the idea is that the values of justice are superficial, however, it seems confused. For what makes sense of friends not needing justice is that they have the relevant values so well internalized”
Card, Claudia. “One Feminist View of Ethics,” from Identity, Character and Morality by Owen Flanagan and Amelie Rorty (MIT Press, 1990).
In My own words:
This paragraph is saying that caring and fairness are two very valuable traits to have in a friendship. Friends are the people are you are supposed to be yourself around and there should not be a set of guidelines or rules to follow to have a good friendship. A Friendship is a relationship in your life that should be appreciated and treated well. You do things for your friends because you care about them and you would do anything for them and the feeling should be reciprocated because a friendship takes both people to make it work. Be friendly to the people in your life because when you need help one day you will have those people to rely on!
Opinion:
I choose this paragraph because out of the entire reading this popped out to me. It interested me because it is something that I feel strongly about. I believe that you should be caring and fair with your friends because friends and family are the most important things to me and when I do nice things for my friends I feel happy and I know that if I need help or someone to talk to I can just call my friends and they will be there for me!
Views on friendship:
1. What is your understanding of ethics of justice and ethics of care? Are they opposite or complementary? Are they useful in understanding what we (should) believe and how we (should) act?
My understanding of ethics or justice and ethics of care is that ethics of care is characteristics that are found in women because women act and react with their emotions and feelings. They are more likely to feel empathy towards others. On the other hand ethics of justice is usually a principle within men because these decisions are based on ethical rules and guidelines and not based on their feelings towards a situation. I believe that they are opposite but also complementary because when you are in a relationship with a male it is nice to have that different view on things and visa versa. They are very useful in understanding what we should believe and how we should act because they give us a set of guidelines to help us understand situations and help us figure out how to react towards things as well.
2. What are qualities of friendship that might help us formulate more general ethical considerations?
The qualities of friendships that might help us formulate more general ethical considerations are the characteristics of being caring towards the ones you call your friends and being fair when it comes to your friendships. Both individuals involved in a friendship need to put the same amount of effort in because that is how a friendship works. I believe you need to be caring person to be fair because someone who is selfish and only thinks about themselves will not be very fair.
3. What is your definition of empathy and can you think of a situation in which you felt empathy towards someone else? What can we learn from it and how could it apply to other, more general ethical situations?
My definition of empathy is to feel sympathy towards others around you when they are feeling down or things are going on in their lives. It also is when you can relate to someone because you have gone through a similar experience. A time that I have felt empathy for someone was when my friend lost someone close to her and I have experienced this before so I understood the pain she was going through. I could relate to her because when you lose someone close to you it is a very hard and I felt I helped her with it all because I was there to support her. We can learn a lot from feeling empathy because you can connect with people and be able to view things in different ways. You can use this in your life because when you understand more about what others go through you will less likely be judgmental or critical of people and their decisions and feelings.
4.Do you believe that too much emphasis on personal caring relationships will encourage many people to become morally apathetic towards larger ethical issues? Why or why not?
I do not believe that too much emphasis on personal caring relationship will encourage people to become morally apathetic towards larger ethical issues. You should emphasize personal caring in relationships because it is a good thing. When people are caring and enjoy supporting others they will be more likely to care about ethical issues. They will be more willing to want to help people because they genuinely care about the well being of others. We need a lot more caring people in the world because I believe that if we did the world would be a lot happier place to live.
MULTI-MEDIA:
I choose “You’ve got a friend” by James Taylor because I think that is a good song to define a friendship or a close relationship. My favorite part of the song is….
“You just call out my name, and you know where ever I am I’ll come running to see you again.Winter, spring, summer, or fall, all you have to do is call and I’ll be there, yeah,yeah,you’ve got a friend”.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEkIou3WFnM